Skip to content

A letter to my heartthrob

December 5, 2007

Dear Mr. Shah Rukh Khan, or SRK as I have begun to call you pyar se,

I watched Karan Thapar interview you on his infamous show Devil’s Advocate. That man has way too much gall, doesn’t he? I have always admired your chutzpah and ability to beguile the masses. So when you bumbled inarticulately through Thapar’s interview, I winced. Please don’t consider me an elitist, foreign-film watching snob, or worse, a non-movie watcher. I am in fact a movie buff. I am also a Bollywood buff. And this year after OSO and Chak De, all my grouses with your acting and star power have disappeared. I shamed my retired and aging father as I hooted at your rockin bod during Dard-e-Disco.

However, a statement you made caught my attention. Thapar asked if you feel a responsibility towards fellow Muslims and felt for them as they were severely repressed in India. Shockingly, you said:

“Muslims are not discriminated against in India.”

and again

“This country has been very very fair to Muslims.”

I am trying very hard to justify you and this statement to those anti-SRK bigots out there, knowing the facts at hand*:

– More than 35% of Muslims live below the poverty line
– Less than 60% of Muslims are literate
– Of those, about 60% of girls go to school.
– 10% of rural Muslims have running water
– Muslims hold 5-10% government jobs

*Govt Report- Sachar Committee 2006, National Census 2001

What frame of reference you ask? Trailing Hindus by 10-70% depending on which stat you are looking at. This doesn’t take into account the Godhra carnage (2000 Muslims killed – thrice the number of Hindus), the Babri Masjid riots, the Meerut riots…we can go on.

Then when Thapar asked you if you felt the need for a Muslim party you said something that brought me back to earth.

“As far as I am concerned, as a normal Indian, we don’t.”

You see, you don’t live in the normal world of Muslims in India. The Sachar report shows police oppression on Muslims, Muslims living in constant fear of alienation and subjugation, Muslims are constantly on the watch for communal politics. You are clearly not one of them.

You don’t have to empathise with them. You certainly don’t have to be “patronizing” as you so clearly said. You find it in yourself to be defensive about terrorism but obviously take no offence to the subjugation of your sect. Sir SRK, if you cannot speak up for India’s largest minority, please don’t do it a disservice by glossing over its ailments.

In fact you are right. I thought – how great it would be for Islam for the man who rests on every Indian’s heart to represent them. But your words show me that under representation is far better than being misrepresented.

Your true fan (of the Star SRK),
N

Advertisements
2 Comments leave one →
  1. Khawatein Voice permalink
    December 13, 2007 3:03 pm

    Read about the plight of Muslim women in India and elsewhere… a comprehensive blog on Muslim women – the true dalits denied human rights… visit “Khawatein Voice” by Haseena Khatun, a Muslim woman married to a Hindu, http://www.khawatein.blogspot.com

  2. the mad momma permalink
    May 23, 2008 12:19 pm

    though every word you said rings true, I want to disagree.. I havent watched the show.I just think that if SRK had said Muslims are a discriminated against lot, there’d have been riots.his staying shut means no one will bother with them either. but his speaking up would have caused more trouble. maybe he chose the lesser of the two evils…that apart you are perfectly right. filmstars lose touch with reality after they rise.. and most forget what life before that was like…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: